443-287-4832

Menu
Serosurvey Design

Introduction

There are many issues to be considered when designing a serosurvey. Many of these steps are common to the design of any type of survey, including:

  • Defining the survey objectives
  • Identifying the target population
  • Determining the survey design
  • Choosing the specimen type

Refer to the WHO Serosurvey Guidelines and WHO vaccination coverage survey manual for details on study design issues.

Learning Objectives

  • Understand potential sources of data and specimens
  • Understand considerations in choosing a specimen type

Topics covered in this module

  • Characterization of different sources of data and specimens
  • Pros and cons of different specimen types used in serosurveys

Contents

  1. Serosurvey Objectives
  2. Target Population
  3. Serosurvey Study Designs
  4. Choosing a Specimen Type
  5. Toolkit
  6. Reference

Serosurvey Objectives

The serosurvey objectives should be developed in consultation with the immunization program and local stakeholders. Consider the following questions in developing the objectives:

  • What is the target population of interest?
    • Are there specific subgroups (e.g., age groups, communities) of interest?
  • What are the vaccine antigens and infectious diseases (e.g., measles, rubella, tetanus) of interest?
  • What question(s) are you trying to answer?
    • Estimate seroprevalence in specific age groups or geographical areas
    • Classify a population based on seroprevalence (e.g., “high”, “intermediate”, low”)
    • Compare seroprevalence between subgroups (e.g., HIV infected and uninfected)
    • Assess trends in seroprevalence over time

While there may be multiple objectives of interest, the study design and sampling will be guided by the primary objective. Refer to Section 2.3 of the WHO Vaccination Coverage Cluster Survey manual and Section 2.2 of the WHO Serosurvey Manual for more detailed information about survey objectives.

Target Population

There are two main considerations when defining the target population:

  • What are the demographic groups of interest (e.g., age cohorts, gender, urban vs. rural setting)?
    • Ensure the selected demographic groups will allow you to answer your question of interest. For example, serosurveys evaluating the impact of mass vaccination campaigns or supplementary immunization activities (SIAs) should include children in the age range eligible for the campaign. Serosurveys to inform which ages to target in future campaigns may require a wider age range to identify immunity gaps in older ages.
  • What is the geographic or administrative level at which your results should be representative (e.g., national versus subnational vs local level)?
    • This will influence the sampling methodology, sample size, logistics and complexity of the survey.

Refer to Section 2.4 of the WHO Vaccination Coverage Cluster Survey manual and Section 2.3 of the WHO Serosurvey Manual for more detailed information about target populations.

Serosurvey Study Designs

There are four main types of study designs used for serosurveys.

  • Designs that use existing specimens collected for other purposes:
    • Residual blood available in a biorepository from other surveys, studies, or surveillance systems
    • Residual blood collected for a clinical purpose at a health facility or laboratory
  • Designs that collect new specimens from survey participants:
    • Serosurveys nested within a survey conducted for another purpose (e.g., Demographic Health Survey or Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey)
    • Stand-alone serosurveys

Characteristic

Existing blood specimens

New specimen collection

Biorepository

Health facility or laboratory

Nested serosurvey

Stand-alone serosurvey

Interaction with human participants

No

Yes

Community-based work

No

Yes

Time

Design and planning

Moderate: Develop sampling frame and obtain specimens.

Moderate: Identify facilities and systems to collect specimens and linked data.

Moderate: Restricted to specimen-collection aspects.

High: All aspects of design and planning required.

Data and specimen collection

None

Low

Moderatea

Higha

Costb

Low cost: Specimens collected from participants for other purposes.

Moderate: Added costs for specimen collection.

High: All general survey and specimen-related costs.

Control over Study Design

Little control: Little to no control over procedure, data availability, and survey quality. Missing data or specimens could result in bias.

Moderate: Less control over the survey design than stand-alone survey which may result in compromises on procedure, data availability, and survey quality.

High: Allows for better control of design, sampling, data, and representativeness of the population of interest

Other

Considerations

Select existing specimen sources that are representative of the target population, if possible.

 

Ensure ethical approval allows for further testing of specimens.

 

Consider if seroprevalence may have changed since the specimens were collected.

 

Additional time, cost, and capacity required to collect specimens (e.g., resources, personnel, community engagement).

 

Results may not be available in a timely manner.

       

Table 1. Comparing study designs for serosurveys
a. Refer to Specimen Collection module for more details

b. For cost, only the primary drivers are listed

Choosing a Specimen Type

  • Different specimen types can be used for serosurveys depending on the antigen of interest. The most common include serum collected from venous blood and dried blood spots (DBS) collected from capillary blood on filter paper.
    • Oral fluid can also be used but may have lower sensitivity than blood.
  • For community-based serosurveys, specimens may either be collected at a centralized blood collection location or within households.
  • Selection of specimen type should consider several factors including but not limited to:
    • Objectives of the serosurvey
      • Not all laboratory assays can be performed with DBS or oral fluid. Refer to module, Assay Protocols.
    • Field conditions for collection of specimens such as:
      • Logistical issues including distance from the laboratory, ability to centrifuge specimens at the site of collection and maintain a cold chain during transport, and where specimen collection will occur (centralized location or household).
      • Training and expertise of staff collecting specimens.
      • Community acceptability of blood collection via venipuncture or fingerprick.
    • Laboratory capacity to test and store specimens at appropriate temperatures. Refer to module, Specimen Collection.

Characteristic

Specimen Type

Liquid blood

Dried blood

Whole blood

Capillary blood

Blood dried onto filter paper

Collection

Venous

Need skilled personnel (i.e., phlebotomist).

Requires additional supplies and equipment.

Risk of hemolysis during collection.

Fingerprick

 

Fingerprick

Consider collecting liquid blood from a subset to calibrate results for DBS using serum.

Transport, Processing, Storage

Requires cold chain.

Requires processing to separate serum from blood within 1-2 days of collection.

Risk of hemolysis during transport.

No cold-chain requirement.

Time-to-processing is less critical.

Testing

Repeated thawing of specimen may result in degradation of antibodies.

Additional elution step required prior to testing.

Not all laboratory assays are validated for use with DBS.

May obtain lower antibody levels than with serum, impacting sensitivity.

Table 2. Considerations for using serum and DBS for serosurveys. Refer to modules, Specimen Collection and Assay Protocols, for more information.

Toolkit

TopicDocumentContext
Serosurvey DesignSerosurvey Design Worksheets and FlowchartGeneric

Reference

World Health Organization Vaccination Coverage Cluster Surveys Reference Manual
World Health Organization Guidelines on the Use of Serosurveys in Support of Measles and Rubella Elimination